Pizzas

Pizza Menu

Fat Boys Pizza

Experience the Authentic Taste of Fat Boys Pizza

When the craving for a delicious, mouth-watering pizza hits, there's no better place to satisfy your taste buds than Fat Boys Pizza in Newburgh, IN. Our locally owned, second-generation family business is dedicated to bringing you the best pizza experience possible. We invite you to make the call and discover the difference that fresh ingredients and expert craftsmanship can make.


Why Choose Fat Boys Pizza?

At Fat Boys Pizza, we believe that the best pizzas are made with passion, expertise, and the freshest ingredients. Here's what sets our pizzas apart:

  • Our dough and sauce are homemade, crafted with love and years of experience.
  • We use only the freshest ingredients, including crisp, fresh veggies.
  • Our pizzas are cooked on a wood-fired grill and brick oven, giving them a unique, crispy taste.

Don't settle for anything less than the best. Reach out to Fat Boys Pizza today and experience the difference for yourself.


Discover the Fat Boys Pizza Difference

What makes Fat Boys Pizza truly special is our commitment to quality and customer satisfaction. Here's why you should choose us for your next pizza craving:

  • We're a locally owned, second-generation family business. We're not just a restaurant, we're a part of the Newburgh community.
  • We've been serving delicious pizzas since 2016, and our 8 years of experience ensures that every pizza is perfect.
  • We offer curbside pickup and delivery through Grub Hub, making it easy and convenient for you to enjoy our pizzas.
  • We stand by our pizzas with a 100% satisfaction guarantee. If you're not completely satisfied, we'll make it right.

Experience the Fat Boys Pizza difference today. Make the call and satisfy your pizza cravings like never before.


Get in Touch with Fat Boys Pizza

Ready to experience the authentic taste of Fat Boys Pizza? Don't wait. Get in touch with us today and let us serve you the best pizza in Newburgh, IN. Whether you prefer to call or visit us, we're always ready to serve you. Remember, at Fat Boys Pizza, your satisfaction is our guarantee.

Menu

Pizzas

7" Indy
Cheese $5.00 / 1 Topping $5.50 / 2 Topping $6.00 / 3 Topping $6.50 / 4 Topping $7.50 / 5 Topping $8.50
10" Small
Cheese $8.00 / 1 Topping $9.00 / 2 Topping $10.00 / 3 Topping $11.00 / 4 Topping $12.00 / 5 Topping $13.50
14" Medium
Cheese $12.00 / 1 Topping $13.00 / 2 Topping $14.00 / 3 Topping $15.00 / 4 Topping $16.50 / 5 Topping $17.50
16" Large
Cheese $15.00 / 1 Topping $16.00 / 2 Topping $17.00 / 3 Topping $18.00 / 4 Topping $19.50 / 5 Topping $21.50
Toppings
Beef, Italian Sausage, Pepperoni. Crumbled Sausage, Ham, Bacon, Onion, Chicken, Mushrooms, Black Olives, Tomato, Green Pepper, Pineapple, Jalapeño

Specialty Pizzas

Supreme Pizza
Sausage, Beef, Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Onions, Tomatoes, Black Olives
Meat Lovers
Sausage, Beef, Pepperoni, Bacon, Ham
Stromboli Pizza
Crumbled Sausage, Onions, Cheese (Comes in Mild, Medium or Hot)
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Ranch Base, Chicken, Bacon, Cheese
Buffalo Chicken
Buffalo Base, Chicken, Cheese
BBQ Chicken
BBQ Base, Chicken, Onions, Cheese
Ring of Fire
Buffalo Base, Spicy Seasoning, Chicken, Banana Peppers, Jalapeños, Cheese

Learn More About

Fat Boys Pizza

Serving the Newburgh, IN area. Fat Boys Pizza provides pizza, sandwiches, appetizers, wings, desserts, and catering services. Neighborhood favorite on NextDoor in 2017, 2018, 2021, and 2023. Can order through Grub Hub. 15% Veteran discounts. Call today.

Watch Video

Play Video
Share by: